How AI can shape our Career Path and boost Earnings?

A Comprehensive review of Reinforcement Learning’s impact on career path planning and applications in People Analytics

Photo by Graeme Worsfold on Unsplash

Building on the foundational ideas discussed in the first part of this article , where I talked about the significance of recommendation systems and reinforcement learning in reshaping HR and people analytics, this next segment promises to delve even deeper in this area.

If you haven’t yet had the opportunity to read the first part, I highly recommend you start Here to gather the foundational concepts on recommendation systems and Reinforcement learning which is crucial for this discussion.

As we go forward, I want to go through the innovative applications of these technologies in designing a career development pathway. The main inspiration comes from an insightful study that we will explore later to see the potential of leveraging reinforcement learning in career planning, with the aim of having financial benefit at the end.

This study is not just theoretical; it’s a peek into a future where data-driven guidance could significantly influence our professional decisions and financial success! However, it’s important to note that while the approach is based on cutting-edge research, its practical application remains a topic of exploration and has not yet been widely proven in the field.

So let’s delve into this concept to see how the intersection of Recommendation systems, Reinforcement Learning, and Career Planning could one day revolutionize our approach to professional growth and success.

The Current State of Career Planning in organizations

Traditional career planning within HR departments has often been a structured, yet tough process and tailored more towards organizational needs than individual goals and visions.

Employees are guided through predefined paths, with promotions and role changes based on tenure, performance, availability, or broad competency frameworks. This one-size-fits-all approach, while organized, overlooks the unique talents, desires, and potential career growth of each individual.

The challenge for HR professionals today is not just in identifying the different array of possible career paths but in personalizing these paths to align with both organizational goals and individual aspirations. The complexity of modern career landscapes, coupled with the dynamic nature of job roles, requires a more flexible and adaptable approach to career planning. It’s here that the limitations of traditional methods become clearly apparent, opening the door for innovative solutions that leverage cutting-edge technologies.

Reinforcement Learning (RL) in Career Planning

At the heart of our discussion lies reinforcement learning (RL), a subset of artificial intelligence that copies the way humans learn from their environment or better to say from their success or failures. By using a system of rewards and penalties, RL algorithms learn the best actions to achieve specific goals. So in the field of career planning, this translates to algorithms that can navigate the vast landscape of career opportunities to recommend paths that maximize long-term growth as well as income.

Career Path Recommendations for Long-term Income Maximization

The paper “Career Path Recommendations for Long-term Income Maximization: A Reinforcement Learning Approach”, presents a new approach to leveraging RL for designing career paths that are not just aligned with individual skills and interests but are also optimized for financial prosperity. So I found this study a testament to the discover more about the potential of RL in designing the traditional career planning methods and how in near future we can make our next career move guided by data-driven insights.

The paper discusses four main techniques: Sarsa, Q-Learning, Deep Q-Learning (DQN), and Advantage Actor-Critic (A2C). It explores how these techniques can help in making better decisions for planning a career to ultimately earn more money over time.

Sarsa and Q-Learning are good for situations where decisions and outcomes are straightforward and can be listed out easily. They work well in simpler settings where everything you need to consider can be clearly defined and put in a table.

DQN (Deep Q-Learning) and A2C (Advantage Actor-Critic) come into play when things get more complicated. Imagine trying to make decisions when there are too many factors to consider, or things keep changing in unpredictable ways. DQN and A2C use something similar to brainpower (neural networks) to navigate these complex situations, making sense of them so we can still make smart choices.

So, to understand how each one works and why they’re useful in this topic, let’s briefly and of course in simple word ;) go over what each algorithm does:

1. Sarsa: Imagine you’re learning to navigate a maze where you can see only where you are and where you could go next. Sarsa is like a strategy where you learn by doing, you take a step, see what happens, and then decide your next move based on both your current step and what you think will happen next. It’s like learning to skate while thinking about your next move to avoid falling.
2. Q-Learning: Now, think about deciding your path in the maze not just by where you are and where you’re going next, but by imagining the best possible outcome at each step, even if it’s not your immediate next move. Q-Learning is a way of learning where you always aim for the best possible future reward, learning from what could happen at your best, not just what you’re planning to do next. It’s like playing chess and always moving your pieces where they can eventually help you win, not just make a good immediate move.
3. Deep Q-Learning (DQN): This is a smarter version of Q-Learning. Imagine you’re playing a video game with so many possibilities that you can’t easily predict the best move. Deep Q-Learning uses computer “brain power” (deep neural networks) to figure out the best moves in these complicated situations. It’s like having a super-smart friend who helps you decide the best path in a really complex video game by learning from playing it over and over.
4. Advantage Actor-Critic (A2C): Think of this as a team strategy where one team member (the actor) makes decisions based on their current understanding of the best move, while another team member (the critic) reviews those decisions and suggests improvements. This combination helps you learn better and faster, making smarter moves by balancing what you think is best (the action) and what could actually work better (the critique). It’s like learning a new sport where one coach teaches you the moves while another gives you feedback on how to do them more effectively, helping you improve quicker.

In essence, these techniques are different ways of learning from experience, with each method offering a different approach to understanding and making decisions in situations ranging from simple to incredibly complex.

Pseudocode

To illustrate how Reinforcement Learning (RL) can be applied to optimizing career paths, let’s look at a simplified pseudocode. This example will show the basic logic behind using RL to make strategic decisions that could lead to the most rewarding career path.

initialize_environment(career_data)

def reward_function(current_state, next_state):
    return next_state.income - current_state.income

for each employee in employee_list:
    current_state = get_initial_career_state(employee)
    while not reached_goal_state:
        action = choose_best_action(current_state, possible_actions)
        next_state = simulate_action(current_state, action)
        reward = reward_function(current_state, next_state)
        update_model(current_state, action, next_state, reward)
        current_state = next_state

    recommended_career_path = construct_career_path_from_final_state(current_state)
    display(recommended_career_path)

This pseudocode represents how an RL algorithm might navigate through different career options, assessing and learning from each decision’s outcomes to recommend a career path that maximizes long-term income.

Used Dataset

The paper utilized two key datasets from Randstad, featuring anonymized work experience records and job vacancy details:

1. Work Experience Dataset: Includes employee IDs, job duration, occupation codes (ISCO), and industry codes (SBI), primarily covering jobs secured through Randstad.
2. Vacancies Dataset: Contains about six million job listings from Dutch websites, with details on salary ranges, occupations, and industry codes.

After preprocessing to ensure data quality, the final dataset includes 200,000 employees and 400,000 work items, highlighting the temporary nature of most placements and providing a comprehensive overview of the job market and salary expectations. The average annual salary in the vacancies dataset is approximately 42,000 euros, with a median salary of 38,000 euros.

Methodology

The proposed methodology for recommending career paths aimed to guide candidates towards sequences of jobs that would maximize their earnings over their foreseeable future. The model focuses on recommending a career path for candidates by considering their work experience, past job applications, and current job market vacancies. The goal is to identify a sequence of jobs that maximizes a candidate’s earnings.

— Inputs

• Candidates: A set of individuals seeking career advice.
• Jobs (J): Available job positions in the market.
• Work Experience (Wc): Historical job positions held by each candidate, including the role and duration.
• Job Applications (Appc): Jobs each candidate has applied to in the past, along with the outcomes (hired or rejected).
• Vacancies (V): Current job openings in the market.

— Model Components

The model comprises four modules:

1. Plausible Jobs Module: Defines the possible jobs a candidate can apply for, based on their current job and work history. This module limits the job options to the most prevalent 142 jobs to manage computational feasibility.
2. Transition Module: Accounts for the uncertain outcomes of job applications. It uses a Random Forest classifier to predict the probability of transitioning from one job to another, considering two approaches
3. Last Job State Representation: Focuses only on the candidate’s last job.
4. Full History State Representation: Considers the candidate’s entire job history, offering a more realistic but complex perspective.
5. Reward Module: Calculates the reward (estimated salary) for each job transition, using a Random Forest regressor trained on the job market vacancies to predict salaries based on job descriptions and industries.
6. Reinforcement Learning (RL) Module: Employs RL algorithms to learn optimal job transition strategies that maximize earnings. The module tests various algorithms to find the most effective ones for recommending high-income career paths.

The model simulates the job market environment through the first three modules, setting the stage for the RL module to learn and recommend optimal career paths. By analyzing past job applications, current vacancies, and individual work histories, the model aims to provide personalized career recommendations that focus on long-term income maximization.

Exploring the Study’s findings and next steps

By analyzing historical data and patterns of career progressions, the algorithms identify which steps or transitions are likely to lead to higher income levels. The beauty of this approach lies in its ability to consider a multitude of factors, from market demand for certain skills to the timing of role transitions, creating a personalized roadmap to financial success.

The study demonstrated that RL algorithms, particularly Q-Learning and Sarsa, could devise strategies that significantly improve individuals’ hypothetical future incomes.

• Income Increase: In scenarios where only the most recent job was considered (Last Job State Representation), the average accumulated income saw an increase of about 5% over baseline models, indicating a tangible benefit from the application of RL in career planning.

However, the study also encountered limitations, notably that RL models did not always surpass baseline models in terms of improving financial incomes. This shortfall was largely due to inaccuracies in predicting transition probabilities, highlighting an area for improvement.

Despite these challenges, the research emphasizes the huge potential of AI in career planning, providing personalized and adaptive career recommendations that respond to market changes and individual circumstances.

Reinforcement Learning in Career planning and Future Possibilities

Integrating reinforcement learning into human resources practices would significantly change how career development plans are made. It allows HR professionals to create customized plans for each employee, aimed at maximizing their earnings, rather than relying on one-size-fits-all advice. However, bringing this idea to life comes with its own set of challenges. There are concerns about the accuracy of the data used, the fairness and ethics of the algorithms, and whether HR departments are ready to use such sophisticated technology.

Looking to the future, RL has the potential to transform HR and career development in a big way. It promises a shift from the traditional career ladder to a more personalized career journey, focused on both professional growth and financial success. This vision of the future is exciting, but it requires HR professionals to embrace new technologies and lead the way in innovation.

Reinforcement Learning in People analytics

The integration of reinforcement learning algorithms is not just about career planning. It can also open up new avenues for enhancing employee development and organizational growth. Here are several use cases showing the impact of RL in People Analytics field:

1. Personalized Career Pathing

As mentioned before, RL algorithms can analyze vast amounts of career progression data to recommend personalized career paths for individuals. By considering an employee’s skills, experiences, and career goals, along with market trends and organizational needs, RL provides tailored advice that maximizes both employee satisfaction and long-term income potential.

2. Talent Retention Strategies

Organizations can use RL to identify career opportunities and learning experiences that align with an employee’s aspirations and growth potential. By proactively offering career development options, companies can increase job satisfaction and loyalty, significantly reducing turnover rates.

3. Skill Gap Analysis

RL can help HR departments analyze current workforce capabilities versus future needs, identifying skill gaps and emerging roles. This enables targeted recruitment and internal training programs, ensuring the organization can adapt to industry changes and technological advancements.

4. Dynamic Succession Planning

By continuously analyzing employee performance, potential, and career trajectory with RL, organizations can more effectively plan for succession in key roles. This dynamic approach ensures a ready pool of candidates for leadership positions, facilitating smoother transitions and sustained organizational performance.

5. Enhancing Diversity and Inclusion

RL algorithms can be designed to factor in diversity and inclusion goals within career path recommendations, promoting equitable opportunities for advancement. By mitigating unconscious bias, these algorithms support a more diverse leadership pipeline and a more inclusive work environment.

Like many AI algorithms, reinforcement learning (RL) holds the potential to significantly influence career planning for both organizations and individuals. As we look toward the near future, it’s becoming increasingly important for companies to consider personalized career paths that align with the unique skill sets and aspirations of their employees. Similarly, individuals can leverage the same approach to carve out the most rewarding and suitable career trajectories for themselves. By adopting this mindset, both parties can create a win-win situation, fostering an environment where employees not only achieve professional growth and satisfaction but also contribute more effectively to their organizations’ success. This collaborative approach to career development, powered by AI and specifically RL, promises a future where career progression is both more individualized and mutually beneficial.

Thanks for reading, Follow me for more content, Stay fresh, be nice! :)